Bella Vita Pizza in Shelter Island

Italian Restaurant
0 reviews


Cuisine: Italian, Pizza

Features: Takeout, Delivery, Seating




      The spare dining area with red and white checked table cloths, paper towel napkins and too loud TV tuned to the History Channel (and not one of their real historical shows) did not inspire great confidence, but we were rewarded with exactly the meal we...More

    thumb Hawk470

      Great local pizza spot if you're on Shelter Island. Really like how they make pies with different flavor combos. Friendly too. They did move, so be sure you have the correct address!

    thumb john w

      Yes, Bella Vita is the most expensive pizza anywhere. I've been eating here for years ever since the previous pizza guys closed up shop and Bella Vita took over. And yes, it's decent pizza. And they are the only game in town so they can...More

    thumb Robert M

Write a Review